Why Half Of US Men Still Buy Into The Meat‑Equals‑Manhood Myth

A new poll has put a number on something a lot of us have suspected for years.

Fifty‑three percent of US men say the carnivore diet feels masculine. Only 10 percent say the same about plant‑based eating.

That gap is the whole story.

The survey, run by the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine (PCRM) with Morning Consult, polled 1,020 American men between May 12 and 14, 2026, and the results landed ahead of Men’s Health Month in June.

When probed further, most men did link diet to gender. Meat sat firmly on one side of that line.

What The Survey Actually Found

The numbers paint a clear picture.

Fifty‑three percent of respondents perceive the carnivore diet, a regimen of nothing but animal products, as masculine. Forty‑nine percent feel the same about beef, chicken, pork, and other meats.

On the other end, 43 percent of men associate plant‑based and vegan diets with femininity. Soy gets singled out: 35 percent view tofu, edamame, and plant milks as feminine foods.

Men aged 18 to 34 were the most likely to attach gender to dinner.

That is the demographic the manosphere has been targeting hardest, and it shows

The Manosphere Is Selling A Health Myth

If you have spent any time on YouTube, TikTok, or X in the past two years, you have met the meatfluencer.

Shirtless, sunlit, carving into a rare steak with the kind of confidence usually reserved for car commercials. The message is rarely subtle: real men eat raw beef, real men drink raw milk, real men do not eat plants.

PCRM’s registered dietitian Noah Praamsma put it plainly in the press release: “Meatfluencers and the manosphere are pushing the disease‑causing myth that consuming meat and milk is manly.”

But the myth has older roots than any TikTok algorithm.

Research from the University of Bath found that men in focus groups initially deny that gender influences their food choices, then within minutes describe being teased, watched, or quietly judged for ordering a plant‑based burger in front of friends.

One interviewee told researchers a plant‑based burger was “ruining my reputation as a man.” Another said he felt he was “sacrificing my manhood” by ordering one.

This is not a fringe feeling. It is the air a lot of American men are breathing.

What The Science Says About Meat And Men’s Health

Here is where the cultural script and the medical evidence sharply part ways.

Diets centered on red and processed meat have been linked, in study after study, to higher risks of heart disease, colorectal cancer, prostate cancer, erectile dysfunction, and reduced fertility. PCRM lists all of these in its statement, and the broader literature backs them up.

A previous PCRM poll found that half of US men still are not aware of the link between meat consumption and colorectal cancer, which gives you a sense of how thoroughly this information has not reached the people who need it most.

The plant side of the ledger looks very different.

A recent study on NAD+ and biological aging we covered showed vegans carrying a cellular age advantage that, on one biomarker, looked like being thirty years younger. Plant‑based eating has also been linked to better blood flow, lower LDL cholesterol, and improved erectile function, none of which exactly screams feminine.

If anything, the “masculine” diet is the one quietly working against the things men say they care about most.

The Soy Estrogen Myth Refuses To Die

The survey hit another nerve worth unpacking.

Twenty‑four percent of respondents said they believe both dairy and soy contain estrogens. That is half right and half very wrong.

Dairy does contain estrogens. Cows are usually milked while pregnant, which is why milk carries measurable hormones linked in research to hormone‑related cancers, including prostate cancer.

Soy does not contain estrogen. It contains phytoestrogens, plant compounds that loosely resemble human estrogen in shape but do not act on the male body the same way.

A 2021 meta‑analysis published in Reproductive Toxicology, pooling data from 41 clinical studies on more than 1,700 men, found no effect of soy or isoflavone intake on testosterone, free testosterone, estradiol, or estrone. None. Regardless of dose. Regardless of study length.

Tofu does not lower testosterone. The data on that question is now boringly settled.

What soy might do, according to other research cited by PCRM, is help reduce the risk of prostate cancer when eaten regularly.

Why This Survey’s Most Interesting Number Is 63 Percent

The headline figure was 53. The most useful figure is 63.

Sixty‑three percent of the men surveyed said they would likely change their diet if they learned the foods they associated with masculinity were harmful to their health.

Read that twice.

The same group that calls meat masculine also says, by a clear majority, that it would walk away once the health stakes are made plain. That is not stubbornness. That is an information problem.

And it is a fixable one.

PCRM also notes that the 2025‑2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans, written in part by authors with industry ties, continue to nudge people toward more animal protein. The cultural and the institutional messaging are pointing in the same unfortunate direction.

The job, then, is not to shame men out of steak. It is to put the actual evidence in front of them and let the 63 percent do its work.

A Few Plant Foods That Quietly Outperform The Stereotype

Some unloved staples that men’s‑health research keeps recommending:

• Lentils and beans for soluble fiber and steadier cholesterol
• Walnuts and flaxseed for omega‑3s and cardiovascular benefit
• Tofu and tempeh for high‑quality protein without saturated fat
• Berries and leafy greens for antioxidants linked to better vascular function
• Whole grains for sustained energy and lower diabetes risk

None of them are feminine. They are just food.

If you are curious about how to actually hit serious protein numbers without animal products, our guide on how to hit 100 grams of vegan protein covers the practical side in detail.

⭐ 4.9/5 Rated by 10,000+ Vegans

More Than 200 Delicious Plant-Based Recipes That Feel Like Cheat Meals, Now at 80% Off!

Join thousands of readers already using this cookbook to cook simple, high-protein plant-based meals they actually enjoy every day.

Explore The Cookbook →

Limited-time reader discount available

What I Keep Thinking About

The thing that stays with me about this survey is not the 53 percent.

It is the silence underneath it. The number of men who, on some level, suspect that the steak‑and‑eggs influencer they keep watching is selling them something more expensive than dinner, but who do not want to be the one at the cookout asking for the bean burger.

Food has carried gender baggage for as long as humans have eaten in groups, and a single poll does not unpack all of that.

But the data has moved. The science has moved. The only thing left to move is the script.

For anyone looking to try plant‑based eating without making a whole identity out of it, our how to start a vegan lifestyle walkthrough is a quiet, low‑pressure place to begin.